BroadRouter

Cline vs Roo Code vs Aider for teams on open models (2026)

By the BroadNet Inference team · 5 min read · Published · Updated

Pick Cline for a maintained VS Code agent with approvals, checkpoints, MCP and Plan/Act models. Pick Aider for a git-first terminal workflow that edits through text formats and so runs on models without tool calling. Roo Code was archived on May 15, 2026; existing users can move to Zoo Code, its community continuation, or to Cline.

Most Cline vs Roo Code vs Aider comparisons were written for teams on a big closed model. With open models the question changes. What matters is whether the agent depends on native tool calls, how much context it sends per step, and how much it lets you control cost. One more thing changed this year: Roo Code is no longer maintained. This comparison uses each project’s own repository and docs, checked on 14 November 2026.

What happened to Roo Code?

Roo Code’s GitHub repository was archived on May 15, 2026 and is now read-only. The README says the extension was shut down, and points users to two places: Zoo Code, a continuation whose core team are former Roo contributors, and Cline, the project Roo Code was originally forked from. Zoo Code is Apache-2.0, keeps Roo’s modes and per-mode MCP restrictions, and publishes a Roo-to-Zoo migration guide.

So in practice this is a three-way choice between Cline, Zoo Code (for the Roo way of working) and Aider. Below, “Roo Code” means the Roo feature set, which Zoo Code carries on.

How do they compare feature by feature?

Cline Roo Code / Zoo Code Aider
Where it runs VS Code extension, plus a CLI VS Code extension Terminal, with an IDE watch mode
Status Maintained Roo archived; Zoo Code maintained Maintained
License Apache-2.0 Apache-2.0 Apache-2.0
How it edits Tools (native or text-based), with approval per edit Native tool calls only Text formats: whole file, search/replace, udiff
Undo Checkpoints Checkpoints (Zoo Code) A git commit per change
Planning Plan and Act modes, separate model each Modes: Code, Architect, Ask, Debug, custom Architect mode with two models
MCP Yes: stdio, Streamable HTTP, legacy SSE Yes, with per-mode restrictions No built-in client documented
Context control Model Configuration, checkpoints Per-mode settings /add, /drop, /tokens, --map-tokens
Custom endpoint OpenAI Compatible provider OpenAI Compatible provider OPENAI_API_BASE

Which one depends least on tool calling?

Aider. Its edit-format docs describe edits as text in the reply, such as search/replace blocks. The model doesn’t need to emit structured tool calls. That widens your model choice: on BroadNet you can run Aider on DeepSeek V4.1 Flash, which BroadNet doesn’t list with tools, and do it on a flat plan. The Aider guide has the setup.

Roo Code is the strictest. Its docs say it uses native tool calling only, with no XML fallback, so a model without solid tool calls fails early. Use GLM 5.3 or Qwen3.8 27B.

Cline sits in between. Its v3.35 release moved to native tool calling for a list of named providers and frontier models, and says other models “continue using the text-based approach”. Either way, the model must follow a strict tool format. Test any model on a short real task, such as “read the README and list the build steps”, before a long session. Our tool calling guide explains what to look for, and the best open model for coding agents picks a model per agent.

Which one spends the fewest tokens?

That depends more on how you use it than on the tool, but the defaults differ:

  • Aider sends a repo map with each request, with a default budget of 1k tokens set by --map-tokens (it can grow well past that when no files are added), plus only the files you /add. /tokens reports the current context size. It’s the easiest of the three to keep lean.
  • Cline and Roo send a larger system prompt and tool definitions on every turn, then read files as the task needs them. Long tasks grow fast. Starting a fresh task per change keeps history small.

On a per-token key, those differences show up on the bill. On an unlimited plan they only affect speed. Our agent token budget post shows how to measure each part, and the token counter sizes a system prompt or file before you send it.

Which is best for a team?

  1. Mixed-experience team in VS Code: Cline. Approval on every edit and command, plus checkpoints, gives reviewers a clear trail. Plan and Act can use different models, so you can plan with GLM 5.3 and act with a cheaper model if your tests pass.
  2. Team already using Roo modes: Zoo Code. It keeps your custom modes and settings. Don’t stay on the archived extension; it won’t get fixes.
  3. Terminal and git-first team: Aider. Every change is a commit with a message, so normal code review and git revert work.
  4. Need MCP servers: Cline or Zoo Code. See MCP with OpenAI-compatible models.

Running several agents at once? Each one in flight needs its own capacity. See running parallel coding agents on a flat rate.

How do you switch agents without losing a week?

  1. Pick one real ticket and run it in two agents, same model, same repository.
  2. Log the request count and tokens from your provider’s usage data.
  3. Compare the diffs, not the chat. Count how many edits you had to fix.
  4. Keep the agent that needed the fewest fixes per ticket.

All three connect the same way. The hub for open models in coding agents lists the exact fields.

Where BroadNet Inference fits

BroadNet Inference is a model provider, not an agent, so it works with all three. Use GLM 5.3 or Qwen3.8 27B for Cline and Zoo Code, where tool calls matter. Use DeepSeek V4.1 Flash for Aider, on a pay-as-you-go key or a flat $60 Full Moon session. BroadNet can’t fix an agent’s own limits, such as Aider’s lack of a built-in MCP client, and it doesn’t serve closed models. Price a month of agent traffic in the LLM API cost calculator, compare model prices on the pricing page, and see plans at inference.broadnet.ai/plans.

Questions

Is Roo Code discontinued?

Yes. The Roo Code repository was archived on May 15, 2026 and is read-only. Its README says the extension was shut down and points to Zoo Code, a community continuation, and to Cline.

What is the best Roo Code alternative?

Zoo Code if you want the same modes and settings, since it continues the Roo codebase under Apache-2.0. Cline if you want the upstream project that Roo Code was forked from.

Does Aider support MCP?

Aider's documentation does not describe a built-in MCP client. Third-party projects wrap Aider as an MCP server so other agents can call it, which is the reverse direction.

Which works best with cheap open models?

Aider is the most forgiving, because its edit formats are plain text and don't need native tool calls. Roo-lineage agents need native tool calling, and Cline needs a model that follows its tool format closely, so GLM 5.3 or Qwen3.8 27B on BroadNet are the safer picks for both.

Can I use Cline from the terminal?

Yes. Cline's README documents a CLI installed with npm i -g cline, for interactive chat or headless runs in CI.

Read as MarkdownAsk ChatGPTAsk ClaudeAsk Perplexity